Which VPN should you choose? Comparison for privacy-conscious users

There are hundreds of VPN providers. Most are not interesting for people who are serious about privacy. This article compares the providers worth considering — honestly, without affiliate bias.

Which VPN should you choose? Comparison for privacy-conscious users

Which VPN should you choose?

There are hundreds of VPN providers. Most are not interesting for people who are serious about privacy. This article compares the providers worth considering — honestly, without affiliate bias.

Read VPN: what it does and what it doesn’t first if you’re not sure what a VPN actually protects you from.


Who this comparison is for

This comparison is for readers who:

  • want to choose a privacy-friendlier VPN deliberately
  • understand that a VPN is only one layer, not a total solution
  • want to choose on tradeoffs rather than marketing

This comparison is not written for:

  • people who only want the cheapest streaming VPN
  • readers who have not yet handled basics like a password manager, 2FA, and browser hardening
  • situations where Tor or a higher-stakes profile is actually the more logical first step

Decision frame

Use the same questions throughout this comparison:

  • what do you gain from this provider
  • what do you give up
  • how hard is adoption
  • how much maintenance does it require
  • who is it a good fit for
  • when is it overkill

If your main goal is simply less tracking and your basics are not in place yet, a VPN is usually not your first gain point. Then passwords, 2FA, and the normal baseline matter more.


What to look for in a privacy VPN

No-logs policy — independently checked Every VPN claims to keep no logs. The question is what an outside party actually checked, and when. An audit is a snapshot of one moment and scopes differ, so read the date and the scope. A claim nobody has checked is only a promise.

Jurisdiction Where is the company based? A provider has to obey the courts of its own country, wherever that is; what it can hand over depends on what it keeps. IVPN’s privacy policy says exactly this for Gibraltar. No jurisdiction is immune: Switzerland, for example, consulted in 2025 on expanding its surveillance rules, and in February 2026 its Federal Council said the draft is being reworked. We found no final decision.

Private payment Paying with a credit card links your identity to your VPN usage. Providers that accept cash or Monero keep your name and bank out of the payment record; Bitcoin is traceable on its public ledger. That makes the account hard to link to you, not you anonymous: the VPN server still sees your IP address while you are connected, and anything you log in to online still knows who you are. Crypto also differs in who handles it: Mullvad and IVPN take it on their own nodes, while NordVPN and Surfshark send it through CoinGate, Windscribe through CoinPayments, and Proton through a third-party processor it doesn’t name. A processor sees the payment as well, so it is one more record that can link the account to you.

Open-source client Is the app code public? Open-source software can be inspected — closed software cannot.

WireGuard support WireGuard is faster and simpler than OpenVPN and is the current standard for new implementations. Providers offering only OpenVPN are behind.

Ownership structure Kape Technologies lists ExpressVPN, CyberGhost and Private Internet Access as its brands, along with Webselenese, a publisher of privacy and security comparison sites. Kape was called Crossrider until 2018, and Malwarebytes classed Crossrider as adware. A company with that past owning several “privacy” brands and comparison sites in the same field is a red flag.


Quick choice

Use this as a first filter, not as the final answer:

If this is your priority Look first at
Giving away as little personal data as possible Mullvad
Good balance of privacy, ease of use, and extra features ProtonVPN
More control and more privacy options IVPN
Mostly convenience, broad coverage, and little manual work NordVPN
Following a new technical approach, but not trusting it blindly yet VP.NET

The comparison

Provider Jurisdiction Latest no-logs check Private payment Open-source WireGuard
Mullvad Sweden Server audit 2024 (Cure53) Cash, Monero, BTC (own nodes) Yes Yes
ProtonVPN Switzerland 2026 (Securitum) BTC (via a processor), cash Yes Yes
IVPN Gibraltar 2019 (Cure53); yearly security audits since Monero, BTC (own nodes), cash Yes Yes
Windscribe Canada None found; app and server audits 2021–2024 Crypto incl. Monero (via CoinPayments), cash Yes Yes
NordVPN Panama Late 2025 (Deloitte) Crypto (via CoinGate) Partial (Linux client) Yes (NordLynx)
ExpressVPN BVI (Kape) 2025 (KPMG, design only) None listed Partial (Lightway protocol) Yes (own version), plus Lightway
Surfshark Netherlands 2025 (Deloitte) Crypto (via CoinGate, not on mobile) No Yes

Per provider

Mullvad — least linked to you

Mullvad works with numbers instead of accounts. You create an account without an email address, username or any personal details. You receive a randomly generated account number.

You can pay with cash by post (literally send banknotes to Sweden), Monero, Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash or credit card. The credit card option is available but links your identity to your account. For crypto, Mullvad says it runs its own nodes and wallets, with no payment company in between. Mullvad VPN AB belongs to Amagicom AB, which Mullvad says is wholly owned by its founders.

The pricing model is simple: one rate, no discounts for longer subscriptions, no tricks. €5 per month (~$5.50 at Mullvad’s conversion), and Mullvad takes 10% off for crypto.

Independent audits: app audits in 2018, 2020, 2022 and 2024; VPN server audits by Cure53 (2020 and 2024), Assured (2022) and Radically Open Security (2023); a web-app assessment by Assured (October 2025); and an account and payment audit by X41 (published January 2026). In 2026 Assured also audited GotaTun, Mullvad’s new Rust-based WireGuard implementation. These are security audits, not a no-logs certificate: the server audits included privacy, but the 2022 and 2024 ones ran on servers set up for the audit, with no customers on them.

What you gain: minimal account data, simple pricing, strong reputation, cash and Monero payment.

What you give up: less consumer convenience than large marketing VPNs, no bundle ecosystem, and a slightly more deliberate setup process.

Choose Mullvad if: keeping your VPN account unlinked from you is the priority and you’re willing to configure the app yourself.

Overkill if: you mostly want an easy default VPN and will pay with card anyway.


ProtonVPN — best choice for balance

ProtonVPN comes from the team behind ProtonMail, based in Switzerland. They have a free tier with, Proton says, no ads and no speed limits; of the services on this page only Windscribe also has a free plan. Paid versions add Secure Core (traffic routes through an extra server in Switzerland, Iceland or Sweden) and Tor-over-VPN.

Open-source apps for all platforms. Securitum has audited the no-logs policy every year since 2022, most recently in 2026, and Proton quotes it as finding no sign that the examined servers log user activity. Cash goes by post and must name your Proton username; Bitcoin only works by upgrading an existing free account, goes through a third-party processor and doesn’t renew automatically.

The organisational structure is more complex than Mullvad: Proton says it has no venture capital investors and is tied to the non-profit Proton Foundation. It is also more commercial, with discounts for longer subscriptions.

What you gain: a strong balance between privacy and convenience, a serious free option, and bundle value if you already use Proton.

What you give up: more account structure and more commercial subscription behavior than Mullvad, with a less minimalist setup.

Choose ProtonVPN if: you also use ProtonMail (combine accounts), want a free option to test, or want Tor-over-VPN and Secure Core.

Overkill if: you do not need Secure Core, Tor-over-VPN, or the broader Proton ecosystem.


IVPN — maximum privacy control

IVPN is less well known but has one of the strongest privacy positions in the market. No email address required, payment in Monero, BTC or cash (cash only for a year or longer, non-refundable); IVPN handles crypto on its own servers and nodes. Multi-hop included in every plan. Its founder says he owns all of IVPN Limited.

IVPN has yearly Cure53 security audits, but by its own account its only no-logs audit was in March 2019: it argues such audits are snapshots and has not repeated them. The eighth security audit (Cure53, July 2026, of its Unlinked Access system) has concluded; IVPN published the results on 9 November 2026.

Slightly more expensive than Mullvad ($6 a month for IVPN Standard against Mullvad’s €5; IVPN lists prices in USD only). Mullvad also offers multi-hop and Monero, so those two alone are no reason to pick IVPN over it; IVPN adds options such as weekly plans and its AntiTracker.

What you gain: more privacy options, stronger control, and payment methods that suit privacy-focused users.

What you give up: a higher price and more complexity than many normal users actually need.

Choose IVPN if: you want the maximum from a VPN and value its yearly security audits and extra options.

Overkill if: you mainly want one reliable VPN to turn on without further tuning.


NordVPN — for mainstream use

NordVPN is a solid choice for people who want a user-friendly VPN without diving into technical details. WireGuard-based (NordLynx), large server network. NordVPN says PwC and then Deloitte have assessed its no-logs policy six times, most recently in late 2025; it says the full report is for subscribers only.

It is not a Kape brand. It shares a holding company with Surfshark (see below) and needs an email address. Only the Linux client is open source. Ideal for people who want to install a VPN and forget about it.

What you gain: convenience, a broad server network, low learning curve, and a low introductory price (renewal costs more).

What you give up: less transparency than the more privacy-focused leaders and a weaker fit if you want cash or Monero payment or minimal account data.

Choose NordVPN if: ease of use is the priority and you don’t need cash or Monero payment.

Overkill if: you want a VPN primarily as a principled privacy measure rather than as a convenience layer.


ExpressVPN is owned by Kape Technologies, formerly Crossrider (see above). It requires an email address, its own payment page lists no crypto option, and its apps are not open source. KPMG’s 2025 report tested the design of its server technology at one point in time, not how it runs over a longer period. High price for what you get.

Surfshark is suitable for unlocking geo-restricted content, and Deloitte checked its no-logs policy in 2025 (full report for its users only). It is still not the choice if privacy is the priority: closed apps and no cash as a listed payment option.

Also note: since their 2022 merger, Surfshark and Nord Security sit under one holding company, operating independently according to Surfshark. If you are consciously diversifying or consciously avoiding that group, keep that in mind.


VP.NET — one to watch (launched June 2025, still without a public audit)

VP.NET names Andrew Lee, who co-created PIA (Private Internet Access) and sold it to Kape, as a co-founder. Its team page also lists former Mt. Gox CEO Mark Karpelès as protocol chief and Bitcoin.com founder Roger Ver.

The technical approach is unusual: VP.NET uses Intel SGX secure enclaves, isolated, encrypted memory regions on the server meant to be out of reach of the operating system and of administrators with software access. VP.NET says the enclave runs a cryptographic mixer that separates your identity from your traffic, and that you can check through Intel’s attestation what is running.

The philosophy: “don’t trust, verify” — privacy by technical design, not policy promises.

Caveats:

  • More than a year after launch, still no published independent audit — “too new” is a less convincing explanation now than it was last year
  • VP.NET says even its own engineers can’t get in, “not with physical access”. Researchers showed in 2025 that SGX does not hold up to that: WireTap and Battering RAM break SGX on DDR4 servers with a cheap device on the memory bus, and WireTap also took the key behind attestation. Intel treats physical attacks as outside SGX’s protection. We don’t know what hardware VP.NET runs
  • No proven track record at scale

What you gain: a more interesting technical trust model than a simple “trust us, we do not log” promise.

What you give up: limited operating history, less established confidence, and more design risk because the model has not been pressure-tested for long enough.

Conclusion: Technically the most interesting new VPN design in years. Not enough history yet to recommend as a first choice — but worth following. If the audit track record builds up, this could change the standard.


What to avoid

Free VPN services (except ProtonVPN free tier) Free VPN services need revenue. Unless paid users fund the free tier, that revenue often comes from your data: traffic analysis, behavioural profiling, or sale to advertising networks. Some are outright malware.

VPN rankings on affiliate sites Search for “best VPN 2026”? The results are almost always based on affiliate commissions, not independent research. The commissions are large: NordVPN’s own affiliate program, for example, pays 40% of a new 1- or 2-year subscription (100% of a first month’s payment) plus 30% of every renewal for as long as the reader stays subscribed (checked November 2026).

VPN as the only privacy measure A VPN changes who sees your internet traffic — from your provider to the VPN provider. It doesn’t protect against tracking cookies, browser fingerprinting, data breaches at services you use, or malware. It’s one layer, not a complete solution.


VPN on router vs. per device

If you have a GL.iNet router, you can set up VPN at router level. All devices on your network automatically go through VPN — including devices that don’t support their own VPN app (smart TV, games console, IoT).

Advantage: one setting, everything protected. Disadvantage: slightly lower speed due to router-level encryption, and it’s harder to toggle per device.

See the GL.iNet setup guide for step-by-step WireGuard configuration on router.


Summary

Priority Recommendation
Least linked to you Mullvad — numbered account, cash/Monero payment
Privacy + features balance ProtonVPN — Swiss, Secure Core, free tier
Maximum control IVPN — multi-hop, Monero, no email address required
Ease of use NordVPN — user-friendly, audited
Follow, but do not recommend blindly yet VP.NET — interesting model, still without an independent audit
Avoid ExpressVPN (Kape), free VPN services

What is probably the right answer for most readers

For most PrivacyGear readers, this is the practical order:

  1. first understand what a VPN does and does not do
  2. only choose a VPN if you have a concrete reason for it
  3. then usually choose between Mullvad, ProtonVPN, and IVPN

If you do not have a clear purpose beyond “do something for privacy”, a VPN is often not the best first step.

Next step

Decide first

Go further

Reviews