Private Space vs Shelter work profile on GrapheneOS: which should you use?

For most GrapheneOS users, Private Space is the better choice: it is built into the OS, needs no extra app, and GrapheneOS itself recommends it over a work profile managed by an app like Shelter. A Shelter work profile still makes sense in one main situation: when you want a second isolated space next to your Private Space.

Private Space vs Shelter work profile on GrapheneOS: which should you use?

Private Space vs Shelter work profile on GrapheneOS

For most GrapheneOS users, Private Space is the better choice: it is built into the OS, needs no extra app, and GrapheneOS itself recommends it over a work profile managed by an app like Shelter. A Shelter work profile still makes sense in one main situation: when you want a second isolated space next to your Private Space.


Who this guide is for

This guide is for people who:

  • use GrapheneOS (or another Android 15+ phone that offers Private Space) and want some apps kept apart from their main profile
  • have seen both Private Space and Shelter recommended and want to know which one to actually use
  • already use Shelter and wonder whether it is time to switch

What this guide does not solve: if you need strong separation between identities (for example a work identity that must never touch your personal life), neither option is the strongest tool. A separate user profile is. See GrapheneOS profiles.


What you gain, and what it costs

Choosing the right option usually gets you:

  • one isolated place for apps you don’t fully trust, such as social media, shopping or Google-dependent apps
  • separate app data, files and accounts from your main profile
  • a separate VPN configuration for that space

What it costs:

  • apps have to be installed again inside the space; you cannot move an existing app with its data
  • some friction when sharing files or photos between spaces
  • a little more battery and memory while the space is running

The core difference

Both create an isolated space inside your main (Owner) profile. The difference is who manages it.

  • Private Space is an Android feature (since Android 15). The operating system manages it and provides its own settings, lock screen and launcher section.
  • A Shelter work profile uses Android’s work profile feature, which was designed for company-managed phones. Shelter acts as the “company” that manages the profile. That means a third-party app holds admin control over the profile.

GrapheneOS put it plainly when Android 15 arrived (October 2024): it “strongly recommend[s]” Private Space “as a replacement for a work profile managed by a local profile admin app”, because it “has better OS integration and isolation”. Apps like Shelter “are given a lot of responsibility and control over the work profile”, while Private Space doesn’t delegate that to a third-party app.


Comparison table

Private Space Shelter work profile
Built into the OS Yes (Android 15+) No, needs the Shelter app (F-Droid)
Who manages it The OS Shelter, as profile admin
Latest release Updated with the OS Shelter 1.9.1, December 2023
How many One, in the Owner profile only One, in the Owner profile only
Can both exist at once Yes, they can coexist Yes
When locked or paused Apps stop completely, no notifications Apps stop when you pause work apps (an Android switch; Shelter itself freezes single apps). A work lock alone doesn’t stop them
Storage after that Can stay unlocked in memory, unless you turn on End session immediately on lock Locked on pause in Android’s default configuration
Notifications while running In your normal list, with a Private Space icon In your normal list, next to your personal ones
Own lock Optional separate PIN, pattern or password Optional separate work-profile lock
Hide from the launcher Yes, optional, but that doesn’t conceal that it exists No, the work tab stays
Separate VPN Yes Yes
Separate encryption keys Yes Yes
Sandboxed Google Play inside Fully supported on GrapheneOS Works
Shared clipboard with main profile Yes by default; GrapheneOS can turn it off Yes (Android’s default; Shelter doesn’t change it)
Extra tools Install available apps (GrapheneOS) Freeze apps, Clone to Shelter, File Shuttle
Deleting it Apps and on-device data gone, no backup All apps and data in the profile gone

Private Space in detail

You set it up under Settings → Security & privacy → Private space (listed under the Privacy heading). Under Private space lock you choose your normal screen lock or a separate PIN, pattern or password. With your normal screen lock, anyone who knows it can open the space too.

Locking decides whether its apps run. When Private Space is locked, Android stops the whole space: apps can’t run in the foreground or background, and they can’t show notifications. Under Lock private space automatically you choose when that happens:

  • Every time device locks (the default)
  • 5 minutes after screen timeout
  • Only after device restarts

That last option matters. If you want apps in Private Space to keep delivering messages, set it to lock only after a restart. It then behaves much like an always-on work profile, and stays open while your phone is locked. Its notifications show in your normal list with a Private Space icon, which gives it away to anyone looking at your phone (on the lock screen their content is hidden by default). Android’s own note on the settings page warns that Private Space is not suitable for apps that must run in the background or send critical notifications, such as medical apps.

Locked doesn’t mean the keys are gone. Android stops the apps but can keep the space’s storage unlocked in memory. GrapheneOS adds End session immediately on lock (off by default): the storage then locks right away and takes strong authentication to open, the way ending a secondary user’s session does. Turn it on if the space is meant to protect data at rest, not just keep apps out of sight.

Hiding is not concealment. Hide private space takes the locked space out of the app list; you reach it by typing “private space” in the app search. GrapheneOS warns on that screen that hiding “doesn’t conceal that you have one”, because other parts of the system may reveal it. Google’s help names people who install apps on your phone or connect it to a computer, other apps, and device logs. Android’s note on the settings page adds that such people may even get access to the space. The Settings entries appear whether or not you have a space, so they don’t give it away.

You can lose it. Private Space isn’t in device backups and can’t be restored to a new device; deleting it removes its apps and on-device data with no backup, so keep what matters elsewhere. If you forget a separate lock, Settings → System → Reset options → Delete private space is the way out. That route asks for your screen lock, not the space’s lock, so someone who knows your screen lock can’t open the space but can delete it.

Other practical points:

  • apps are installed as separate copies inside the space, and app data can’t be moved in. GrapheneOS adds Install available apps, which installs apps you already have in the main profile into the space (without their data)
  • while it’s unlocked, you can share files and photos across spaces with the share menu and the photo picker
  • The clipboard is shared by default. GrapheneOS added Cross-profile shared clipboard on the same settings page: the default, Follow defaults, shares it both ways; Disallowed blocks it in both directions, and two in-between options allow only copying in or only copying out. This also covers copying between Private Space and a work profile; what was already copied stays available until the next copy
  • A VPN in your main profile doesn’t cover the space: set one up inside it. Private DNS is device-wide, and GrapheneOS strongly recommends turning it off when you use a VPN in a secondary profile
  • Sandboxed Google Play inside the space has its own settings at Settings → Security & privacy → Private space → Sandboxed Google Play

Shelter work profile in detail

Shelter is an open-source app that creates a work profile and then manages it for you. It adds a few tools Private Space doesn’t have: freezing apps so they can’t run in the background, Clone to Shelter (Work Profile) to install an app from your main profile into the work profile, and File Shuttle for files between profiles.

The downsides:

  • No new release in nearly three years. The latest is still 1.9.1 from December 2023, built for Android 14. Its README calls the app maintenance mode, since it mainly uses built-in Android functions, and promises adapting it to new Android versions; a September 2026 commit says a revamp is coming. Privacy Guides still lists it, but tells people on Android 15 or later to use Private Space instead. An admin app with no recent release is not a comfortable long-term position.
  • It holds admin control over the profile. Shelter says this gives it an extensive list of permissions inside the profile, comparable to a device admin, and that some features ask for more outside it. Privacy Guides warns that you place complete trust in its developer. Version 1.9.1 has no internet permission, and we found no use of Android’s network logs, security logs or wipe functions in its code, but an update could change that. This is exactly the part GrapheneOS prefers the OS to handle.
  • Work contacts can cross over. They can show up in your personal contacts and dialer. Block Contacts Searching in Shelter’s settings stops that.
  • The OS gives it less polish. Android can’t assume how a work profile should behave, so it leaves much of the interface to the managing app.

Who should choose what?

Choose Private Space if:

  • you use GrapheneOS, or another phone on Android 15 or later that offers it
  • you want one isolated space for apps you don’t fully trust
  • you want it locked and out of the app list when you’re not using it

Keep or add a Shelter work profile if:

  • you already use Private Space and want a second isolated space. There can only be one Private Space per device, and GrapheneOS confirms “you can still use a work profile alongside it”.
  • your phone runs Android 14 or older, where Private Space doesn’t exist

Use a separate user profile instead if:

  • you need the strongest separation GrapheneOS offers, for example for a separate identity
  • you want no shared clipboard and no sharing through the share menu, and an End session that purges the keys from memory
  • you’re fine with switching users instead of having apps side by side

If someone can make you unlock the phone, hiding won’t protect you. See the duress PIN guide.


When this is overkill

For many readers, neither is necessary yet. If your app permissions, passwords and basic settings aren’t in order, start there. GrapheneOS first setup covers that.

A good stopping point for most people: one Private Space for the apps you trust least, locked when you’re not using them. Only add more spaces when a real reason shows up.


Conclusion

On GrapheneOS, Private Space has replaced Shelter for most people. It’s built in, managed by the OS, recommended by GrapheneOS, and when locked its apps are stopped and out of sight. Shelter is now mostly useful as a second space next to Private Space, or on phones too old to have Private Space.

If you currently use Shelter, switching isn’t urgent, but it’s worth doing when you next reorganise your apps. You’ll need to install the apps again inside Private Space and log in again.


Next step

Decide first

Go further