Signal and Molly review — the standard for encrypted calls and messages
Signal is the encrypted messenger we recommend to most people, because of how it is built rather than how it is marketed. Molly is a hardened version of Signal for Android.

Signal and Molly review
Signal is the encrypted messenger we recommend to most people, because of how it is built rather than how it is marketed. Molly is a hardened version of Signal for Android.
Who is this for? Anyone who wants to replace WhatsApp with something that takes privacy seriously. Molly is for Android users who want to go one step further than standard Signal.
What makes Signal different from WhatsApp?
Both apps use end-to-end encryption. The difference is not in the message content but in everything around it.
Metadata: WhatsApp is owned by Meta. Message content is encrypted, but much of the metadata around it is visible to WhatsApp (EEA privacy policy). WhatsApp says other Meta apps can’t use that data for ads, apart from a few purposes such as optional linked accounts; we can’t check that from outside (see WhatsApp privacy explained). Signal deliberately collects minimal metadata. On its page of government requests it says it has no access to “messages, calls, profile information, group information, contacts” and other content and metadata, and it publishes what it handed over (signal.org/bigbrother).
Sealed Sender: Signal uses a technique where its own servers don’t need to know who sent a message in order to deliver it — while the recipient can still cryptographically verify who actually sent it. The sender identity is encrypted before transmission and only revealed to the recipient, not to Signal’s infrastructure in between.
Open-source: Signal’s protocol and app code are open-source, so anyone can check them. The Android app also uses proprietary Google libraries for some features (Molly’s README). WhatsApp’s apps are closed-source, so that check isn’t possible.
No advertising model: Signal is a non-profit. No ads, no data sales, no investors expecting returns on your usage data.
Specifications
| Property | Signal | |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption | Signal Protocol (E2E) | Signal Protocol (E2E) |
| Metadata collection | Minimal | Extensive (Meta) |
| Open-source | Yes (app code; the Android app also uses proprietary Google libraries) | No |
| Owner | Signal Foundation (non-profit) | Meta |
| Phone number required | Yes (sign-up without a number is in Android beta) | Yes |
| Disappearing messages | Yes (30 seconds to 4 weeks, or a custom time) | Yes (24 hours, 7 days or 90 days) |
| Price | Free | Free |
Signal in practice
Disappearing messages: Set a timer per conversation: Signal offers 30 seconds, 5 minutes, 1 hour, 8 hours, 1 day, 1 week or 4 weeks, or a custom time. Off by default, but recommended for sensitive conversations.
Note to Self: Signal has a “Note to Self” chat with yourself. Useful as an encrypted clipboard between your linked devices.
Payments (MobileCoin): Signal has a built-in payment feature via MobileCoin. Signal Support says it isn’t available in every country. It is not the app’s main purpose.
Phone number as identity: The regular Signal app requires a phone number for registration. You can use a separate number as long as it can receive SMS or a verification call. Since usernames and phone-number privacy shipped, Signal no longer shows your number by default in your profile to people who haven’t already saved it. People who have your number saved in their phone’s contacts still see it (Signal Support).
Without a phone number (beta): Signal is testing sign-up without a number in its Android beta (version 8.28 or later). “Signal Login” costs a one-time USD 2.99 via Google Pay or Apple Pay and gives you an Account ID and a Recovery Key instead of a number; if you lose both, Signal can’t recover the account (Signal Support, 8 October 2026). Signal describes it as a beta feature only.
Molly — the hardened Android fork
Molly is an independently maintained fork of Signal for Android. Same messages, same protocol, but with extra security options Signal doesn’t provide.
Our recommendation (19 October 2026): Molly is on hold for new users until it ships a release that catches up with Signal. Its latest release is from 31 July, is 15 Signal versions behind and still lacks a security fix Signal shipped (see how up to date Molly is). Use the official Signal app instead, also on GrapheneOS (see GrapheneOS first setup for the install routes). If you already use Molly, see what to do now.
What Molly adds:
- Passphrase encryption: Molly can protect its local database with a passphrase. Signal encrypts the database too, but keeps the key protected only by Android’s KeyStore (Molly’s wiki).
- RAM shredding + auto-lock: Molly wipes sensitive data from memory and can lock itself automatically under conditions you set.
- Push without Google: In Molly’s Settings → Notifications → Delivery service you choose FCM, WebSocket or UnifiedPush; if FCM isn’t available, Molly falls back to WebSocket by itself. UnifiedPush needs a MollySocket server (the project advises running your own) and doesn’t work on linked devices.
- SOCKS proxy and Tor: Route the app’s traffic through a proxy or Orbot.
- Additional hardening: Molly also adds options like unknown-contact blocking and more extensive backup management. Moving a Signal backup into Molly needs a Molly version that matches or is newer than the Signal version that made the backup (Molly’s README). On 10 November 2026 Molly is based on Signal 8.19.2 and the latest stable Signal for Android is 8.34.2, so a backup from current Signal won’t import yet. Signal has also moved Android’s on-device backups to a new cross-platform format (Signal blog, 28 September 2026), so see the Signal setup guide before you switch.
One app since December 2025: Molly used to come in two versions, Molly and Molly-FOSS. Version 7.68.5 merged them into a single, fully open-source app: Molly replaced Google’s proprietary FCM library with its own implementation, and location sharing now uses OpenStreetMap instead of Google Maps (Molly changelog). Molly’s README and download page still describe two versions, but both of its F-Droid repositories now serve the same app (on 10 November 2026 the same APK file, signed with the same key).
Availability: Molly is not in the Play Store. Install via Molly’s own F-Droid repository, via Accrescent, or directly as an APK from GitHub:
- F-Droid — add the Molly repo for automatic updates
- Accrescent — via a privacy-focused app store
- GitHub APK — direct download
Who makes Molly, and how up to date it is (as of November 2026)
Molly is made by a small team. Almost all Molly-specific code comes from one developer, valldrac, and the project’s GitHub organisation lists three public members. Molly is funded through Open Collective: on 10 November 2026 it showed an estimated annual budget of about USD 12,600 and a balance of about USD 44,300. The README names NLnet, Bahnhof, Cloudsmith and JetBrains as supporting organisations. The team is also building Flatline, its own soft fork of the Signal server.
Updates are running months behind. Molly’s README promises an update every two weeks, but that hasn’t held in 2026. The latest release, 8.19.2-4 on 31 July 2026, is based on Signal 8.19.2, while the latest stable Signal for Android is 8.34.2 of 30 October (8.35 is in beta). Before that there was a gap from 29 April to mid-July. The team says merging Signal’s changes is its bottleneck: “We’re late on updates, sorry!” (15 June 2026), and on 2 October that merging Signal “is our bottleneck and delays updates”, when it released a tool to speed this up. Molly’s own changelog adds that builds which fall too far behind risk “Signal server incompatibility”.
A known calling bug is unfixed in Molly. CVE-2026-113380 lets someone on a call with you flood the call so that hanging up doesn’t fully end it: the audio, and perhaps the video, can keep running. It affects RingRTC, Signal’s calling library, before version 2.72.0. The record gives it a CVSS score of 9.3 (NVD’s own analysis is still pending). Signal for Android has carried the fix since September 2026. Molly 8.19.2-4 uses RingRTC 2.69.5-1, and by our reading of its source that build lacks the fix. Users raised this on Molly’s tracker on 22 October; no team member has replied there. Since 4 October users also report that messages stop arriving on 8.19.2-4, again without a reply from the team.
What this means for you: the team has not announced an end. Its last post is from 2 October and its last code change on the main branch from 8 September. But no release has shipped since 31 July, so Signal’s fixes don’t reach Molly. Molly stays on hold for new users (checked 10 November 2026); we’ll look again when a release catches up.
If you already use Molly
- Our advice (7 November 2026): move to the official Signal app, because of the unfixed calling bug above. Until you have, don’t take Molly calls from people you don’t trust.
- If you stay anyway, check Molly’s releases page every so often, and update as soon as a new release appears.
- To move: make a backup in Molly now and keep your Signal PIN at hand. Molly’s README says Molly backups can be restored in Signal and the other way around.
- If messages stop arriving or Molly stops working, switch to the official Signal app. Signal and Molly can be installed on the same phone; with the same number, one of them has to be a linked device.
Who uses what?
Signal (default): For everyone who wants to replace WhatsApp and doesn’t want to go deeper. Install, invite contacts, done.
Molly: For GrapheneOS users, people with a higher profile, or anyone who doesn’t want Google services in the Signal stack, once it is up to date again. On hold for new users since 19 October 2026; until then, those readers use Signal too.
Caveats
Phone number required: For maximum anonymity, a phone number not linked to your identity is needed. That’s an extra step outside the app.
Contacts must also use Signal: End-to-end encryption only works if both parties use Signal. Group migration from WhatsApp takes time.
Molly follows upstream Signal with a delay: The project aims to merge Signal’s features and fixes every two weeks, with security patches applied as soon as they are available. In 2026 the delay has been months, not weeks: see how up to date Molly is.
Pros and cons
Pros
- Sealed Sender encrypts the sender identity before transmission, so Signal’s servers don’t need to know who sent a message
- Open-source app code; non-profit ownership with no advertising model
- Molly is fully open-source since December 2025 and works on GrapheneOS without Google Play (WebSocket or UnifiedPush notifications)
- Molly adds passphrase encryption and RAM shredding — sensitive data is actively wiped from memory, not just left encrypted at rest
- Disappearing messages with configurable timers per conversation
Cons
- Phone number required for registration — an extra step for maximum anonymity
- End-to-end encryption only works if both parties use Signal — group migration from WhatsApp takes time
- Molly is months behind upstream Signal as of November 2026 (latest release 31 July, based on Signal 8.19.2) and lacks a security fix Signal shipped, so it is on hold for new users
Conclusion
Signal is the best WhatsApp replacement for most people — free, open-source, minimal metadata. Molly would be the choice if you’re on GrapheneOS or want to eliminate Google dependencies, but for now we don’t recommend it to new users: its latest release is from 31 July 2026, far behind Signal and without a calling-bug fix. We’ll look again when a release catches up. If you already use it, we advise moving to Signal.
Both are free. There is no reason to keep using WhatsApp if you are serious about privacy.
Getting started
1. Install Signal
Download Signal from the official source: signal.org/download/ for desktop, the Play Store or App Store for mobile. Register with a phone number.
2. First settings
Tap your profile picture in Signal to open Settings. Turn on disappearing messages for new conversations via Settings → Privacy → Default timer for new chats (iPhone: Settings → Privacy → Disappearing Messages). Choose a timer that fits how you communicate; it applies to new chats you start, so set important existing chats one by one. Then check your PIN under Settings → Account, section Signal PIN: Create a PIN if Signal shows that, otherwise Change your PIN is where you change it. The PIN keeps your profile, settings and contacts stored with Signal encrypted, so they come back when you reinstall. In the same place, turn on Registration Lock: nobody can register your number with Signal again without the PIN. Write the PIN down; if you forget it when registering again, Signal locks you out of the account for 7 days. More settings, in order, in Setting up Signal.
3. Invite contacts
If you give Signal access to your contacts, it shows which of them already use it. Invite the people you message most often. One active group is enough to make Signal feel useful — you don’t need to convince everyone at once.
4. Molly instead of Signal (on hold)
Molly is on hold for new users since 19 October 2026 (see how up to date Molly is); on GrapheneOS, use the Signal app for now. Once Molly is up to date again, the steps are:
- Install: open molly.im/fdroid/ on your phone, tap one of the two repository links, choose Add in F-Droid and then install Molly; either repository gives you the same app. Or install it via Accrescent.
- Notifications without Google: in Molly, Settings → Notifications, under Push notifications: set Delivery service to WebSocket, or to UnifiedPush if you have a MollySocket server (not on a linked device).
- Starting fresh (new to Signal, or a second number): register Molly like Signal, and turn on database encryption when Molly offers it.
- Moving from Signal with the same number: registering Molly with your number moves the account to Molly but not your messages; for those you need a backup, and that only works when Molly’s version is the same as or newer than your Signal app’s (Molly’s migration guide). The guide’s order: write down your Signal backup passphrase, optionally switch the phone offline, make a backup in Signal, uninstall Signal, install Molly, turn on database encryption if you want it, then choose Transfer or restore account → Restore from backup and pick the backup. The guide still uses Signal’s old menu names; current Signal makes the backup under Settings → Backups → On-device backups (see the Signal setup guide). Keep the backup folder until Molly has restored it, and re-link Signal Desktop afterwards.
- Keeping the Signal app as well: add Molly as a linked device instead of registering it.
Next step
Choose this if…
Signal is the default choice for anyone replacing WhatsApp. Molly is on hold for new users for now; once it is up to date again, choose it only if you have a real reason for additional local protection or a Google-free Android stack.
- WhatsApp privacy explained — what WhatsApp actually collects and why switching makes sense
- Recommended privacy apps — Signal in the context of your broader app setup
Already have this?
If you already use Signal or Molly, set up disappearing messages and PIN protection before thinking about heavier options.
- Setting up Signal — which settings still make a difference
- GrapheneOS first setup — running Molly on a Google-free Android setup
Want to go further?
Signal is the endpoint for most people. If communication security is a more serious concern, look at your broader situation.
- Profile: stalking or domestic abuse — communicating safely when you are being monitored
- XMPP guide — a decentralised option with no fixed provider