Search engine comparison: DuckDuckGo vs Startpage vs Brave Search vs Kagi

DuckDuckGo, Startpage, Brave Search and Kagi all promise private search, but they differ in where their results come from, what they protect and who they suit.

Search engine comparison: DuckDuckGo vs Startpage vs Brave Search vs Kagi

Search engine comparison: DuckDuckGo vs Startpage vs Brave Search vs Kagi

DuckDuckGo, Startpage, Brave Search and Kagi all promise private search, but they differ in where their results come from, what they protect and who they suit.

Who is this for? Anyone who wants to move away from Google Search but wants to understand what the alternatives actually do — and where they fall short.


Comparison

DuckDuckGo Startpage Brave Search Kagi
Index source Bing (mostly) Google + Microsoft Bing Own index Own index + major search providers
Tracking (their own claim) None None None None
Account required No No No Yes (paid)
Cost Free, with ads Free, with ads (paid Ad-Free in some regions) Free, with ads (paid Premium in Brave browser) From $5/month (USD)
Results independent of Google/Bing No No (via Startpage proxy) Yes Partly
Customisable results Limited Limited Yes (Goggles: re-ranking rules) Yes (pin/demote per site)
Country / owner US Netherlands (EU); part of System1 (US ad-tech) US (Brave) US
Browser extension Yes (+ own browser) Yes Built into Brave browser Yes

DuckDuckGo

DuckDuckGo is for most people the first alternative to Google. It is free, straightforward to set as the default search engine in any browser, and stores no personal profile.

Results come mostly from Microsoft Bing, supplemented with its own crawler and specialised sources such as Wikipedia for direct answers. This means result quality depends heavily on what Bing has indexed.

When it works well: everyday searches for well-known topics, products, news from major media.

When it falls short: recent or niche content, small websites, technical documentation from less well-known projects.

Privacy approach: per its policy, no search history and no tracking cookies; your IP address is only used temporarily, and queries are kept only anonymously. Ads are based on the results page you’re viewing, not on who you are; ad clicks are handled by Microsoft’s ad network, which DuckDuckGo says has committed not to tie them to a profile.


Startpage

Startpage anonymously forwards your search query to its search providers — Google and Microsoft Bing — and returns the results, without them seeing your IP address, browsing history, or account link. Startpage acts as a privacy layer on top of Google’s (and Bing’s) index.

This is the most pragmatic choice if you want Google-quality results but object to Google’s data collection model. You get largely the same results Google would give you (Startpage says they are not 100% identical), but Google does not know it was you.

Startpage is incorporated in the Netherlands and falls under European privacy law (GDPR).

Ownership: Startpage is owned by the Dutch company Surfboard Holding BV and, by its own account, has been part of System1 (NYSE: SST), a publicly-traded US ad-tech company, since December 2018 (the investment ran through Privacy One Group). System1 lists Startpage among the sites it owns and operates and consolidates its revenue. Startpage’s position is that it runs as a separate business unit from the Netherlands, that its Dutch team keeps control of privacy decisions and privacy-related technical changes, and that its privacy policy is unaffected. We found no report of a policy breach. It’s still worth knowing that the parent company’s business is advertising.

When it works well: anywhere Google works well — recent content, niche topics, non-English searches.

Caveat: your results remain dependent on Google’s index and algorithm. If you object to Google as a company and not just to tracking, Startpage is not a true decoupling — and it is part of an ad-tech company (see above).

Privacy approach: per its policy, no IP address stored (except to block abusive bots), no search queries stored, no ad profile. Startpage earns revenue from non-personalised ads alongside results. A paid Ad-Free subscription with an account exists in some regions; Startpage says searches are never linked to that account.

Startpage vs just using Google

If your real question is “Startpage or Google itself?”, this is what changes when you search through Startpage instead of google.com:

Google directly Startpage
Results Google’s, personalised Mostly Google’s (plus Microsoft Bing), not personalised — two people typing the same query get the same results
What Google receives Your query plus your IP address, cookies, device, and account (if signed in) Per Startpage, only the query text, sent by Startpage, with no IP address, cookies, or profile attached
Search history Can be saved to your Google account and used across Google services Not stored
Ads Personalised from your profile Contextual, based only on the query (sponsored links come from platforms such as Google AdSense; only non-identifying system data is shared, for click-fraud prevention)
Local results (“pharmacy near me”) Automatic, from your location Not automatic: add your town to the query or set a Search Location in Settings
Opening a result Directly Directly, or via Anonymous View (a Startpage proxy, so the site sees Startpage instead of you)

What you give up: personalisation and automatic local results, and a search history tied to your Google account. Anonymous View doesn’t allow forms and some scripts, so interactive sites may not work, and it is not a replacement for a VPN or Tor: it puts Startpage in the middle of the connection instead of Google.

What you don’t escape: Google still sees the query text itself, so what you type can still be revealing. And you are shifting your trust from Google to Startpage, a company that is part of an ad-tech firm (see Ownership above).

Practical default: if you like Google’s results but not the profile that comes with them, Startpage is the lowest-friction switch: largely the same results, no retraining. Just add a place name to local searches. If you mainly want to stop depending on Google altogether, pick Brave Search or Kagi instead.


Brave Search has its own crawler and its own index, independent of Google and Bing. That makes it the only free one of these four that is structurally separate from the two major indexes.

Brave itself says its index is still being refined. For niche or recent content Brave Search can fall short — not because it inherits Bing’s limitations, but because a new independent index simply takes time to grow.

Brave Search is part of the Brave ecosystem (also Brave Browser). You do not need to use Brave Browser to use Brave Search; it is available as a search engine in any browser.

When it works well: general queries, technical topics, English-language content.

When it falls short: recently published pages, small websites in smaller languages.

Privacy approach: no profile, no account required, results from its own index. Brave does keep query text with platform, country, language and date, without anything that links it to you. Search shows private ads; the paid Search Premium removes them and only works in the Brave browser.

Note for Brave Browser users: Brave Search has an opt-in “Google fallback mixing” option: for queries where Brave’s own index falls short, the Brave browser anonymously checks Google, mixes those results in, and sends them back to Brave Search so it can improve. It only works in the Brave browser, is off unless you turn it on, and lives in Brave Search’s own settings (search.brave.com → Settings → Google fallback mixing), not in the browser’s. Brave says it has no effect on your privacy (Google can’t link the query to your account, Brave doesn’t keep it), but with it on your results are no longer drawn purely from Brave’s own index.


Kagi

Kagi is a paid search engine with no ads. Results combine its own indexes with anonymised API calls to major search providers and specialised sources: licensed ones include Brave, Mojeek and Yandex, and for Google- and Bing-type results Kagi says it uses third-party API providers as an interim step (Kagi blog, late 2025).

Kagi offers three individual plans (USD, plus sales tax): Starter ($5/month, 300 searches), Professional ($10/month, unlimited searches), and Ultimate ($25/month, adding premium AI models in Kagi’s Assistant). There is also a free trial of 100 searches, and Duo ($14/month for 2) and Family ($20/month for up to 6) plans that bring the per-person cost down. Kagi itself suggests starting with Starter and moving up if you run out.

The distinguishing feature is control: you can raise or lower individual websites in your personal results, block sources or give them priority, and tune the search engine to your own use. Brave’s Goggles also re-rank results, but through shared rule files rather than per-site choices in the results.

An account is required. Kagi stores your settings but commits not to build a profile for advertising purposes — that business model simply does not exist for a paid service.

When it works well: if you are willing to pay and value control over your search results. Power users who want Google-quality results but want to avoid Google’s business model.

Caveat: requires an account and a paid subscription — there is no free tier for ongoing use (the trial is a one-time 100-search allowance). Incorporated in the US, under US law.

Privacy approach: no ad tracking, no data selling. An account is required, but Kagi’s policy says queries are only logged temporarily for debugging, not linked to your account; Privacy Pass lets you authenticate anonymously.


Which one to choose

Most readers: start with DuckDuckGo as the default and Startpage as a regular fallback. Two tabs, two extra seconds of effort, and you only give Google data for the searches where you deliberately decide it is necessary.

If you want to structurally avoid Google: Brave Search as the default, Startpage only when Brave genuinely falls short.

If you are willing to pay for quality: Kagi — the most complete privacy-friendly search experience, but not free.

iOS/Safari users: Safari only lets you pick from its own short list (Apple publishes none; Mojeek names Google, Yahoo, Bing, DuckDuckGo, Ecosia). Apple’s iOS 27 guide gives two routes, Settings → Search → Search Engine and Settings → Apps → Safari → Search Engine, and we couldn’t test them on an iPhone: if you don’t see one, use the other. DuckDuckGo is on the list; Startpage, Brave Search and Kagi are not. Instead: Startpage’s own app, the Brave browser for Brave Search, Kagi’s Safari extension, or the engine’s website on your Home Screen (Share → Add to Home Screen).


Getting started

Setting DuckDuckGo as default

  • Firefox (desktop): Settings → Search → Default search engine → DuckDuckGo
  • Brave (desktop): Settings → Search engine → under Normal Window, Change → DuckDuckGo → Set as default. Private windows have their own engine (Brave Search out of the box): do the same under Private Window
  • Chrome (desktop): Settings → Search engine → Change → DuckDuckGo → Set as default. If it isn’t in the list (it is in the EU): Manage search engines and site search → Add (next to Site search), URL https://duckduckgo.com/?q=%s, then its ⋮ menu → Make default
  • Safari (iOS 27): Settings → Search → Search Engine, or Settings → Apps → Safari → Search Engine (see above) → DuckDuckGo

Private windows: in Firefox they follow your default unless “Use a different default search engine in private windows” is switched on (same Search page); in Brave, set both as above.

Adding Startpage as a fallback

On desktop, the “Make Startpage your default search engine” prompt on startpage.com installs Startpage’s browser extension. If you’d rather not install an extension: Firefox (region Netherlands) and Brave already have Startpage in their engine list; elsewhere, add it in your browser’s search settings. In Safari on iPhone that isn’t possible (see above).


Next step

More control over your browser

Background